Get Your Premium Membership

Intangible Ingredients

Poet's Notes
(Show)

Become a Premium Member and post notes and photos about your poem like Sara Etgen-Baker.


When Mother and I cooked in her kitchen, we often referred to Granny’s recipe cards. Frequently, though, the cards just listed the ingredients without exact quantities; and all too often the recipe’s vague language frustrated me. “Mother, what does use enough flour to make stiff dough mean? How much is a pinch of salt? What is a scant of this? Exactly how much is a spoonful? And, what does simmer until it smells heavenly mean? “Recipes aren’t meant to be precise; they’re merely meant to jog the memory of how to make those dishes.” “Well, if the recipes aren’t accurate why do you use them. Besides, you know the recipes by heart so why do you keep the cards?” “True. Granny’s recipes are inexact and slightly out-of-date. And, yes, I can make most of her recipes with my eyes closed. I guess,” she murmured blinking back the tears, “I just don’t have the heart to throw away the recipes.” “But why?” I insisted. “I just can’t explain it to you.” She turned away from me and continued cooking. All too often I watched Mother take out a single recipe card and just linger over it. I soon realized that perhaps the knowledge the cards evoked wasn’t limited to the information contained in their instructions. Maybe Mother just wanted to hear Granny’s voice and remember the past. Perhaps holding Granny’s recipe card while she stirred and sifted allowed Mother to remember her own mother. Maybe the cards helped her recall family and the precious intangible ingredients with which the finished product would be imbued.
old recipe cards smell of long-ago spices stained, dog-eared, imbued

Copyright © | Year Posted 2023




Post Comments

Poetrysoup is an environment of encouragement and growth so only provide specific positive comments that indicate what you appreciate about the poem.

Please Login to post a comment

Date: 9/25/2023 4:00:00 AM
Ahhh!! A very nice trip down memory lane. We have a few recipes that have been passed down from my mother to me to my daughters. Mostly are memorized. My mother was the best cook and only she could cook certain foods the way she did to create that wonderful flavor. She had a talent for it/me I just cook so we don't go hungry. Thanks for sharing this one with us and for dropping by my page. Sara
Login to Reply
Etgen-Baker Avatar
Sara Etgen-Baker
Date: 9/25/2023 4:18:00 AM
Thanks for stopping by, Sara. Glad you enjoyed the trip down memory lane. Thanks for sharing your recipe/cooking stories. My mother and grandmother were both fantastic cooks...did it by feel. Me, not so much so. I now go for something quick and easy, but it's not often tasty. I enjoy reading your poems....have a great day, the other Sara :-)
Date: 9/20/2023 7:03:00 AM
A very definitive and wonderful new creation my good friend. I recall my mom doing much the same when cooking. As if she was recalling perhaps her mom or her grandmother! A definitive fav for my growing list. God bless you my good friend.
Login to Reply
Etgen-Baker Avatar
Sara Etgen-Baker
Date: 9/20/2023 7:48:00 AM
thanks, Robert, for stopping by and for commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed the poem...and am ever so grateful for you faving it. Have a blessed day, Sara
Date: 9/20/2023 6:28:00 AM
A touching story of mom, Sara. She passed a lot on to you that I can see in you and love. Excellent Haibun, my love. Your Haiku was a great closing touch. Write On! Big Bear Hugs, Bill
Login to Reply
Etgen-Baker Avatar
Sara Etgen-Baker
Date: 9/20/2023 7:49:00 AM
thank you, dear hubby, for your kind words and continued support of my poetic endeavors. I appreciate your big bear hug. I needed it today....hugs back, me :-)
Date: 9/20/2023 5:42:00 AM
This is a precious piece of nostalgia. Is it true story? Nothing like passing tried and true recipes down to the next generation. I fear it's gradually fading out though. Many young women simply have no desire to cook a great meal
Login to Reply
Woody Avatar
Tom Woody
Date: 9/20/2023 9:16:00 AM
My wife is Asian so getting good meals every day. Thx
Etgen-Baker Avatar
Sara Etgen-Baker
Date: 9/20/2023 7:50:00 AM
thanks for stopping by, Tom. And yes, it's a true story. Yes, passing on those types of small traditions are fading. I learned to cook alongside both my mother and grandmother. Cooking is a dying art amongst some women...but then there's all those cooking shows. Oh my. Have a great day and a great meal sometime today. smiles :-) Sara
Date: 9/20/2023 5:38:00 AM
This is so deeply emotive and heartfelt, yes maybe she just wanted to hold onto the memories left and relive them through reading her recipes etc. i really felt this poem. Your poems are always evocative and meaningful, and lingers on even after reading. My favorite from my granny is custard, she makes the best custard ever. But she lives in another city so its not always i get to enjoy. Love the “old ago spices” in your haiku too: such nostalgia and memories. Brilliant haibun
Login to Reply
Etgen-Baker Avatar
Sara Etgen-Baker
Date: 9/20/2023 7:53:00 AM
Thank you, 'Ink,' for visiting and reading my poem. I appreciate your kind comments. I'm glad my poem touched you and lingered for a while. That means a great deal to me. Custard sounds wonderful. My grandmother and mother made the best German Streuselkuchen. Both have passed so I make it for myself sometime in the fall or winter. It's a heavy coffee cake...baking it ignites memories of them for me. I appreciate your heartfelt and sincere comments. You get me, smiles, Sara
Date: 9/20/2023 5:36:00 AM
Sara, I can't tell you what reading this has meant to me! The swell of emotion was swift and deep! I have all of my grandmothers old recipes and some were torn envelopes or slips of paper and all had the exact same pinch of this and such! You nailed it, it's the feeling that they give me and yes I can hear her voice and see her baking me cookies when I was a boy! This is a treasure!!! Happy Wednesday!!
Login to Reply
Etgen-Baker Avatar
Sara Etgen-Baker
Date: 9/20/2023 7:47:00 AM
Oh wow! Thanks, Mike, for reading my poem. I'm so grateful that reading it struck a chord with you. Thank you for sharing your own experiences about recipe cards and your grandmother with me. Your comments meant the world to me. Enjoy your day, smiles, Sara

Book: Reflection on the Important Things