Poetry Forum

home recent topics recent posts search faq

Poetry Forum. A poetry forum dedicated strictly to poetry. Poets can use this poetry forum for poetry workshops, sharing poetic techniques, discussing aspects of poetry, poetry publishing, and the poetry industry. Poetry forum members can enter poetry contests, post poems, and participate in the #1 poetry community on the internet.

Community Soup Bowl
Introductions
New to PoetrySoup? Introduce yourself here. Tell us something about yourself.
Threads
1138
Latest post
1/16/2018 7:59 AM - Oliver Furlong
How do I...?
Ask PoetrySoup Members how to do something or find something on PoetrySoup.
Threads
299
Latest post
1/8/2018 8:06 AM - peter walsh
PoetrySoup Notes
Info and comments from the PoetrySoup Team.
Threads
2
Latest post
1/14/2018 9:42 AM - Ibidun O.
Collaboration
Collaborate on a poem or external project.
Threads
11
Latest post
Poetry Critique
Be Gentle
Post here if you're new to receiving a critique and you want "gentle" feedback on your poem. Constructive criticism only. PLEASE Only Post One Poem a Day!!!
Threads
332
Latest post
1/6/2018 12:51 PM - Lesa Rodden
High Critique
For poets who want unrestricted constructive criticism. This is NOT a vanity workshop. If you do not want your poem seriously critiqued, do not post here. Constructive criticism only. PLEASE Only Post One Poem a Day!!!
Threads
1143
Latest post
1/19/2018 3:25 PM - Laurie Woodward
Poem Editing and Help
Do you need help editing a poem? Maybe English isn't your first language. Post poems or request help with a poem or english here.
Threads
19
Latest post
1/17/2018 9:19 AM - Titus LLewellyn
Poetry Talk
Writing Poetry
Ways to improve your poetry. Post your techniques, tips, and creative ideas how to write better.
Threads
98
Latest post
Poetry Everything
Discuss your favorite poems, poets, and poetry books - analysis, ideas, hidden meanings, random thoughts, etc.
Threads
87
Latest post
Looking for a Poem
Can't find a poem you've heard once? Looking for a poem for a special person or an occasion? Ask other member for help.
Threads
40
Latest post
12/29/2017 5:59 AM - KAREN CROOT
Outside the Bowl
Post information about other useful poetry related websites and contests. Also report poetry scams.
Threads
50
Latest post
11/3/2017 1:48 PM - Lodigiana Poetess
Non-Poetry Talk
Love and Romance
Don't Post Poetry Here!!! Seeking relationship advice, romantic ideas or just want to express your feeling - Post Here!
Threads
30
Latest post
Fun and humor
Don't Post Poetry Here!!! Everything to make us smile - anecdotes, stories, fun things to do, etc. But NOT Poetry.
Threads
53
Latest post
12/9/2017 1:20 PM - Gayle Rodd
I just need to talk...
Don't Post Poetry Here!!! Talk about anything or need a shoulder to cry on? Share your thoughts and emotions here:
Threads
99
Latest post
1/15/2018 9:45 AM - Faraz Ajmal
Publishing
Publishers
Know of any good publishers? Tell us about them here.
Threads
16
Latest post
12/28/2017 3:02 AM - Stella Ban
How to...
Have you published a book. Tell others how you did it.
Threads
9
Latest post
Self-Publishing
How do I do it myself?
Threads
7
Latest post
My Book(s)
Are you a published poet? If so, tell us about your book.
Threads
17
Latest post
12/29/2017 11:01 PM - Tony Brady


What's going on
Forum users online 2   Forum members online 0   Forum guests 2

Threads 3450   Posts 6492   Forum members 48050


Recent posts
1/19/2018 3:25:22 PM
Topic:
Upon Wind's Wings

Laurie Woodward
Posts: 3
Stephen Wilson-Flo wrote:
As I understand it, poems can be for self exploration, family, friends and fellow worshipers. Or it can be for a wider audience. For this to be more appealing to a wider audience, I would rewrite this without the archaic language. In my opinion, if poetry is relevant in today's world, it should be written in the modern idiom. I can't think of a modern published poet with any wide readership who uses this kind of style. It should be an easy fix, should you choose to do it. Best wishes!





Actually, the purpose of this poem was to express a feeling that couldn't be accurately described in less poetic terms. The feeling itself was a poetic one and called for more than plain words to capture it.

I can see your point about modern language. The four words where I used 'thy' or 'thine', instead of 'your', I really felt that the word 'your' was just a bit crude for the feel of the poem, or inelegant at best. The intention was to speak to the wind in a worshipful way, 'your' felt too familiar and too casual.
1/19/2018 3:18:22 PM
Topic:
Upon Wind's Wings

Laurie Woodward
Posts: 3
Ollie Furlong wrote:
A very beautiful and well-balanced poem, it doesn't bother me the last paragraph is 4 lines long. The soul of a real poet is in here, you have touched mine, and I thank you for that. Amazing.



Wow! Thank you very much!
1/18/2018 11:26:39 PM
Topic:
Don't Shoot the Messenger

Jack Webster
Posts: 52
i agree with Bob A. I think this is very good as is.

There is an opportunity, if you wish, to extend the coffee metaphor: coffee is something that wakes people up...
1/18/2018 11:13:37 PM
Topic:
Tinsel

Jack Webster
Posts: 52
i think your three strongest metaphors are the jolly tunes being her confidant, the garland and tinsel being her jury, and the souls being plucked like birthday candles deforming the icing. I think they are profoundly original and dynamic in a way that clearly and crisply conveys the inner experience of the tragedy.

i think your weakest stanzas are the ones describing the crying. the descriptions are notably lush (perhaps bordering on too beautiful, though this is a matter of opinion), but the moment you rely on saying plainly the person is crying, you've already stated directly they are sad, and indirectly told the reader they should be sad too. After that, there's no real way to be subtle about evoking the emotion within the reader, and vivid descriptions of the crying just become redundant or simply for the sake of imagery as they are not conveying anything new poetically, its just more and more and more: she's not just crying, but the tears are sparkling, and rolling, and they are big tears that (even fantastically) come down the steps, and soon there are so many of them she might just float away through the door like Alice in Wonderland.

i think you could convey all of the grief intended with the description of the crying simply by extending the birthday/ holiday theme to wrapping paper: her face crumpled like gold and red wrapping paper, torn, and discarded in the bin.

mixing the Christmas imagery with the birthday cake imagery was slightly disorienting to me, but i love both, so not what to suggest. normally I'd suggest stick to one or the other, but I'm not sure its bothersome enough to discard either of your very authentic metaphors.

I would suggest rephrasing "birthday cake candles", as cake is redundant. if you're plucking birthday candles, its natural to assume or visualize a cake. if you wish to keep the word cake, i would rephrase as: ...souls can be plucked/ like candles from a birthday cake... that way cake is necessary as a noun and not redudant as an adjective.

I would remove the line: ...no one wants to lick. this line makes the poetic meaning of the icing ambiguous, and the acting of licking (in this case trying to savor something sweet) may be seemingly sensual in nature. if the linez were: ...souls could be plucked/ like candles from a birthday cake,/ leaving deformed icing (end of stanza) - i think there is an idea that the icing is the sweetness and happiness of those left behind and how it is damaged by the act of taking and the absence of that source of light. With the line about licking, it asks the readers to determine what isn't icing that is lickable that the icing represents. licking is such a physical act that if the icing is supposed to represent something intangible the verb licking is misleading. if the icing is intended to be the body of the deceased, rendered "un-lickable" by the accident and the taking of the soul, then this becomes a potentially uncomfortable line.


thank you for sharing. i hope something i said ends up being of some use.

good luck
edited by superlativedeleted on 1/18/2018
1/17/2018 7:02:24 PM
Topic:
Changing Seasons

Beatriz Gomes
Posts: 3
I have no experience in critique someone's poems so I really liked yours,is very well done.
1/17/2018 12:50:35 PM
Topic:
Changing Seasons

levi johnson
Posts: 1
Any feedback on this verse? Thanks
1/17/2018 9:19:39 AM
Topic:
Adding Photos

Titus LLewellyn
Posts: 1
Hi There,

I just wondered if it possible to add a photo from my desktop. I'm having difficulty adding a photo to my poem. I am a premier poet here.

Thank you, Titus
1/16/2018 7:59:19 AM
Topic:
Hello fellow poets

Oliver Furlong
Posts: 3
I'm new to Poetry Soup, and I'm delighted to have found this online community. Does anyone know of any face to face poetry communities in London, UK? I have found plenty of Open Mic Poetry nights, but wondering if there are any groups that meet up?
I'd describe myself as a sensitive soul, a romantic, a spiritual seeker, and prone to deep thinking and looking for meaning in most things around me. I feel that writing, and poetry, in particular, is something that I need to channel as it pours through me, and I love it so much. I try to write every day, on my way to work or after getting home, around looking after kids.
1/16/2018 3:33:11 AM
Topic:
Upon Wind's Wings

Oliver Furlong
Posts: 3
The thrust of the poem is imagining yourself letting go, eyes closed in the feeling that the wind caresses your cheeks and your hair, and being carried away by that feeling, where the soul blends with the element of the wind itself. There are 2 words that stick out for me which distract me from being totally carried away, and they are; "ministration" and "satin". For some reason, they jar with the flow of the other words that evoke the wind.
1/15/2018 9:29:39 PM
Topic:
Hoping some critiques

Beatriz Gomes
Posts: 3
Stephen Wilson-Flo wrote:
There is a lot of sincerity here. I believe you feel this very deeply so first, let me assure you comments I make are about the poem's effectiveness not its honesty. I would call this a self-revelation poem, to enlighten oneself. For a wider audience, I would "show" more and "tell" less. For example "my mouth can not attend my sorrows not anymore", what does that mean? It sounds poetic, but what does it mean. In my opinion, this cries out for specifics, "show" don't "tell". For example, what's the story about addressing her as "forewoman". This might be a confessional poem in which case, excuse me, the speaker dishes the dirt. As unflattering as it sounds, we readers have a voyeuristic need to imagine ourselves there. Let the reader take that the journey with you.
edited by Stephen Wilson-Flo on 1/15/2018

I appreciate the critique, very helpful.
I was influence by Emily Dickinson letters to Susan when writing this poem, their love is very strong and deep, I just wanted to write something they would have.
edited by quiet speaker on 1/15/2018
1/15/2018 2:30:36 PM
Topic:
Hoping some critiques

Stephen Wilson-Floyd
Posts: 33
There is a lot of sincerity here. I believe you feel this very deeply so first, let me assure you comments I make are about the poem's effectiveness not its honesty. I would call this a self-revelation poem, to enlighten oneself. For a wider audience, I would "show" more and "tell" less. For example "my mouth can not attend my sorrows not anymore", what does that mean? It sounds poetic, but what does it mean. In my opinion, this cries out for specifics, "show" don't "tell". For example, what's the story about addressing her as "forewoman". This might be a confessional poem in which case, excuse me, the speaker dishes the dirt. As unflattering as it sounds, we readers have a voyeuristic need to imagine ourselves there. Let the reader take that the journey with you.
edited by Stephen Wilson-Flo on 1/15/2018
1/15/2018 2:16:59 PM
Topic:
Upon Wind's Wings

Stephen Wilson-Floyd
Posts: 33
As I understand it, poems can be for self exploration, family, friends and fellow worshipers. Or it can be for a wider audience. For this to be more appealing to a wider audience, I would rewrite this without the archaic language. In my opinion, if poetry is relevant in today's world, it should be written in the modern idiom. I can't think of a modern published poet with any wide readership who uses this kind of style. It should be an easy fix, should you choose to do it. Best wishes!
1/15/2018 11:22:05 AM
Topic:
Upon Wind's Wings

Oliver Furlong
Posts: 3
A very beautiful and well-balanced poem, it doesn't bother me the last paragraph is 4 lines long. The soul of a real poet is in here, you have touched mine, and I thank you for that. Amazing.
1/15/2018 9:45:24 AM
Topic:
What to do, I m feeling ashamed

Faraz Ajmal
Posts: 7
My dear frienrs, my name is Faraz and i m a 15 years old guy, well I m from Pakistan and currently doing my O levels, well everything was perfect, I was doing tol from always, but just before our Cambridge papers, they took our pracrise exams and I m ashamed to say that I got really bad numbers, it s for second time in my history, first was when I was in class 3 and now, I just don t know how to face the class tomorrow because today I was absent and my brother tols me that this mews has become really popular, everybody was talking about it, I m feeling really ashamed to go to class tomorrow as everyone will say that Faraz what happened to you, my mother was really angry but she later assure me that she trust me and she s sure that I ll again do top in my Cambridge exams which are in May. But here s the point, it take me 5 years to build up a respect and it s fallen in just one second, now I again have to built it and wait for another seven months for the next papers whixh will be Cambridge, there results will come in August, I just don t know how to face my classmates and teachers. My Chemistry teacher never like me and now she has an additional point to dislike me, further this was the first time that the boys and girls were competating, and everybody was saying my name, so I ve also lost my reputation I was thinking of building in girls as they didn t know that I was topper, this was my chance but it s ruined
1/15/2018 1:21:36 AM
Topic:
Hoping some critiques

Beatriz Gomes
Posts: 3
. Love You.
My dear forewoman, laughed about us today yet? It's a new day here -- our nights awake, our stories made -- sky is now waiting to grasp the sun back of the another pace of Earth; The sea insisted to talk to me the other day but I couldn't hear him at the non-expected embrace of my sister arms, I told her that and she laughed -- When I was a prayer I would stand so much bravery onto people grounding on me, but my dearly, stations passes through us for so long. Do you pray for us? cause you don't have to, I know you don't. You were right all along, I'm a fool. Is it to selfish to pray for you to come back our home?-- individualism "has me talkin'" -- my mouth can not attend my sorrows not anymore... at this point, nearby on envy, I wonder if are still spaces on you to learn, how can you do that?! -- We, the ones that love and dies for our loves have this manner to think our hearts know it all -- The forewoman grasps the hole world from the concept till the my world's end -- When I die please, let me go knowing that you loved me, that you touched me, that you held me, philosophy me on you, woman! because of you I'd never be still. Held by held you let you go off me.
edited by quiet speaker on 1/15/2018
edited by quiet speaker on 1/15/2018
edited by quiet speaker on 1/15/2018
edited by quiet speaker on 1/15/2018
1/14/2018 9:42:59 AM
Topic:
Poll Question: Featured Poetic Forms...

Ibidun O.
Posts: 2
Yes.
1/14/2018 1:18:34 AM
Topic:
Upon Wind's Wings

Laurie Woodward
Posts: 3
Gentle wind, please
Go not from me.

Rather hold me in thine uplifting arms.
For thy tender ministrations are my sustenance
Each satin, sweet caress a blessing.

Bold wind, please
Go not from me.

Rather wrap me in whirlwinds' chaos
That play with my garments and tease at my hair
Flowing over, around and through me like a river

Storm wind, please
Go not from me.

Rather entwine me in thy heart
Let me feel thy power, to lay waste and to rend.
Then, when my body fails, rend from it my soul
That it may fly always with the wind
1/12/2018 7:48:31 AM
Topic:
How Wonderful It is

Joe Nguyen
Posts: 1
How Wonderful it is

How wonderful it is,
When I find your love
Bird swimming
Fish flying
Sun rising on my shoulders
And on the rolling clouds, Flowers blooming.

How wonderful it is,
When my heart filled with your blessings
Earth rejoicing
Air chanting
Life praising.

How wonderful it is,
When You are my dreams
And all my thoughts are full of your mercy
For, your compassion fills my world
Ev'ryday I sing your glory.

How wonderful it is,
When You are my life
My whole life is thirsting for You, above
Thanks be to You, my sweet Lord Jesus Christ
Sprinkle my life, please, with your eternal love.

How wonderful when my life rests in your caring hands.
How wonderful when I'm one of your children.
How wonderful when You are with me, always.
And how wonderful I am your lowly servant.

Joe Hung Nguyen
1/11/2018 11:57:14 PM
Topic:
Still Child?

Snehika Vijay
Posts: 1
Still Child?




With a blinding smile

I just realised,

I'm getting old in life

But the child in me is still alive.




That sometimes turns me into an imbecile,

But all's forgiven

As long as get to skip tiles

And chomp on fries.




Have I grown up at all?

Oh yes I did quite a lot,

Because now it's the child in me

That keeps me alive.




It's the child in me

Who reminds me to smile,

Tells me it's ok to cry,

Asks me to get up and fight.




Its the child in me

Who daydreams and drools,

Shows me stars when there is no moon,

Helps me survive punctuated with a smile.










Constructive criticism is welcomed

Thanks in advance

Happy reading!!
1/10/2018 4:51:25 PM
Topic:
Don't Shoot the Messenger

Bob Atkinson
Posts: 227
Sweet



Powered by AspNetForum 6.6.0.0 © 2006-2010 Jitbit Software