One That Got Away Poems | Examples

List of Member Poems

The one that got away

My love are you near?
My love are you away ?
My love why won’t you stay?

As eyes gets older one thinks the mind is forever stuck 
As eyes gets older  one thinks of the found memories 
As eyes gets older one thinks of the sadness that came.

We met with smiles and glee
We met under the trees 
We met with fury and anger 

We played till sunrise to sunset 
We played and hide under the trees 
We played and dance in the rain 

Do you remember the last night we touched 
Do you remember the last night we danced 
Do you remember the last night we fought 

As you go to another do you still remember my name 
As I go to another will I still remember your name
As we are in another arms do we still call on one another 

Remember me when you’re old 
Remember me when you’re under a tree 
Remember me when you hear our songs
 
As I open my eyes I throw a rose under the tree we use to hide 

I grow old while you’re forever stuck 
For as it is I who can’t move on 
And I leave a rose by your memory of what you are now 

When my eyes close and I think my last thought 
I see you again and now we are both in the stars.

Premium Member Cherishing the One that Got Away

High school love life... memorable with sheer delight
prevailing still against oblivion's attack!
Such is a romantic reminiscence lingering in my heart
since I experienced being love-stricken as a teen-ager...

Oh, those red paper roses
enclosing fresh white ones
scented sweetly with baby cologne
made me feel I was the very apple of his eye...

Then love notes wholeheartedly penned 
(though copied) held me spell-bound
midst his "My ever dearest" greeting 
and "Very sincerely yours" closing...

Yes, high school love life
proved that "I was not abnormal"
who was only in love with academics
because I believed that he and I were mutually in a relationship...

...Now, I can only bask with thrilling moments
letting exuberance gripped me 
when talking about my high school "crush"
while thanking God* for His love allowing me to keep what I cherish.

*1Thessalonians 5:18 In every thing give thanks: for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus concerning you.

February 11, 2026
1st place, "A Time For Us" Poetry Writing
Sponsored by	JCB Brul; judged on 3/3/2026

Premium Member The One that got away

26 years ago we met 
kept in touch over the years 
seeing each other once or twice 
texting a lot when we can 
thinking about each other a lot 
I'm always with someone though 
never alone to find my way and explore 
now you're moving out of the country 
will we ever see each other? 
was or is our love doomed? 
was it ever loved to begin with? 
I want to know 
don't you want to know? 
if we could have ever been 
we always fall short for the ones we love 
leaving broken hearts to mend 
but the scars are forever there to stay overthinking won't heal the heart


The One that Got Away

The one that got away
Is one you never really had 
Someone worthy would’ve stuck around
Through the good and the bad

The one that get away
Only did you a favor 
Because that’s not a flavor 
That you really wanna savor

The one that got away 
Was only around for the good
They wouldn’t stick by you in hard times
Like a real man or woman would

The one that got away
Really didn't elude you
They only out the way 
So that you could do you

The one that got away
Wasn't the one at all
But the sum of all the other lames 
With whom you shan’t involve

Premium Member One That Got Away

It's been years since we spoken
Most things hadn't changed at all
Our youth had started to dwindle 
But her beauty It could not fall

Back the we had big dreams
Though the we could change 
I laugh when think about them 
They are optimistic and strange

The one dream I had back then 
The one I wished had come true 
Was to be in love and stay forever
I wanted to spend my life loving you

To this day you will always be
That one lover that got away
And as I look at you right now
You're just as beautiful today

THE ONE THAT GOT AWAY

     MANY moons ago
     MARY met a male.
     MARK was his name.
     HARK to their tale.
     HARD to catch was he,
     HARE like was his gait.
     HERE ends the story,
     HERS was far too late


Premium Member The One That Got Away

Was Santa pushed? let the Jury decide
The Jury are gunning for Terry's hide
Terry then started to wail
Because they denied him bail 
They then charged him with violent Santacide. 

"Not guilty you cretins it wasn't me" 
Judge asked" are you pleading insanity "? 
While the Judge was distracted 
Terry moved quick and acted 
Hopped over the court railing and was free.


For now anyway


Written 30th November 2022

Premium Member To the One That Got Away

Thank you,
          the one that got away.
          It's no use wondering
            what might've been
        We were never meant be.
              I do wish you well.

                    Thank you,
           the one that got away.
           A little birdie told me
           you did steal the heart 
    of another; I wish you both the best!
       It's the way destiny intended it.

                    Thank you,
           the one that got away.
           Our spark of romance
        never lit as we were much
         too young to understand
           what love meant then.

              Thank you so much,
             the one that got away,
            because you've led me
       to my true love, my precious
                jewel of a wife.
      It's the way destiny intended it.
Date written: 07/05/2020

Premium Member The One That Got Away

With eyes so deep and dark, I could get lost
soul-sinking into them; with a mouth
tasting of berries, and with hands
that held magic in their touch,
he was the one that got
away. . . if only
I knew what would
have happened
had he
stayed.

For Silent One's Contest: The One That Got Away

The One That Got Away

I think she knew, I wasn’t sure,
About the way I felt,
That every time she spoke to me,
My heart would almost melt.
Her long dark hair enchanted me,
I loved her perfect smile,
We’d talk meaningless trivia,
So I could stay a while.
I once sent her a valentine,
The words I still recall,
But I was shy and nervous then,
Her, confident and tall.
On holiday, a postcard,
I did send to her address,
Perhaps if I had asked her out,
She’d maybe have said yes.
Few years ago I found out,
That she lives in USA,
She’s something of an expert,
In corrosion so they say.
She told me of her children,
And I told her about mine,
I asked if she recalled me,
Yes, her memory was fine.
So she’s the one who got away,
Though never cruel or mean,
But last time that I saw her,
We were both only sixteen!

Premium Member The One That Got Away

We came together to look out from 
our respective balconies
He lived in the opposite house from me
This went on all summer, I felt all warm and fuzzy 
The day he left for college he waved goodbye to me

I looked sad, I felt bad, from now on it was 
summer love for me.
The next time I saw him he had grown taller,
My heart skipped a beat it was a repeat of a visual treat
He caught my gaze and set it ablaze
But this time around he made it a point to talk to me.

We would catch glimpse’s of each other 
Like the sun catches the fresh new leaves
Love blossomed this year, it was summer love for both 
under the shadow of the balcony.

His father held an Army Job and got a transfer
He left one day from the house opposite to me
Time flew by, and we moved our separate ways
He was my first love, the one that got away.

The One That Got Away

THE ONE THAT GOT AWAY.

The pleasant odour of her bodily juices on my sheets,
Crumples of her blood red lipstick stains on my cheeks,
The sweet, soft brush of her hands and finger prints,
Her resonant smooth voice that made my eyes squint,
Her dark radiant skin,
Flawless, as though painted by the most delicate hand,
Her impeccable mango chin,
Fine-made, like a carefully carved brown slate
That flimsy light dress,
Casually following the contouring of her curved shape,
Those wild expressionless eyes,
Luring my lust into her attractive snares,
She is the memory of one night and a day,
She is the one that got away…

The One That Got Away

One day,
Even your voice will fade
To a dull echo far behind my thoughts.
And maybe then,
Ill be free.

Or perhaps,
I will go on
Hearing your voice down vacant hallways
Calling me nearer
And you'll stay.

Whichever you choose 
I will not argue.
I will not resist.
For I would rather remember how you are in the moment,
Than a soft ache 
In the back of my mind
Constantly reminding me of a nameless absence 
Not even I 
Dare name.

The One That Got Away

Falling for her was like summer rain,
First drizzle, then hurricane;
With thunders, with lightning, heavy and fast,
Meant to dishevel, but never to last.

Being with her was an autumn fire,
Vibrant and quiet, a bright red desire.
For she was fresh coffee brewed in the morning,
And you were vodka down her throat burning.

She was Sundays sleeping in with your T-shirt on,
She was nights spent late, talking ‘till dawn,
But you were bare feet on cold ground,
An old toy in a box of lost and found.

Falling out of love with her
Was made of details in a blur.
A door slammed, a few regrets,
Late nights buried in cigarettes,

Voices breaking, ‘could have been’s,
Driving off roads made of dreams.
Her, a wild tale without age,
You, who loved her page by page.

The One That Got Away

The one that got away (Ten word challenge-2 Contest sample)


An AMBIVALENT mood engulfs me, as BITTERSWEET memories
meander in my mind.I was 15 she was 17,yes an older woman.
She was so ARCANE, mysterious, and FLAMBOYANT at the same time.
She was the QUINTESSENCE of sophistication, a LUSCIOUS ripe fruit
waiting for a TACTILE experience.
I was so innocent, so QUIESCENT in my thoughts, I felt I needed
an INTERCESSOR, to offer my IMMOLATION of love to her.
So, I asked my best friend to approach her for me, and ask her to dance.
They danced the night away together, yes she was the one that got away!


Sample for ten word challenge-2 contest
10 obligatory words to be used highlighted
in capital letters.
Give it a try!
Looking forward to your entry!

John Derek Hamilton
October26,2016

Sub Categories

Looking for the formal definition, structure, and history of this poetry form? Visit the Poetry Dictionary entry below. Then return to explore how PoetrySoup members bring the form to life through their own poems.

Get a Premium Membership
Turn off ads, get more exposure for your poetry, and get more features with a Premium Membership.
Book: Diverse Voices: The Poetry of Human Rights and the Pursuit of Peace