Get Your Premium Membership
Vijay Pandit
(Click for Poet Info...)

Upon reading my poem

 

I revised my bio

To tell you what's relevant:

In this space I exist

For the love of writing poems

 

Like a budding flower

I don't much wish to ponder

Harshness of wind and sun

Cherishing instead

The kiss of morning dew

Till a big storm goes through

Blowing away my petals

 

Knowing I always yearned

For the tiny smile you offered

Upon reading my poem

Are You Curious?

Blog Posted by Vijay Pandit: 2/19/2022 8:56:00 AM

I have been wondering how PoetrySoup ranks winning poems in non-premium contests. I am assuming that sponsors select placements (1,2,3, etc.) but do not rank within placements. I have chosen a recent winning list from Brian's contest as an example. I chose this because Brian has a larger population under first place and it's easier to see the pattern in a larger population. Here is my obeservation: Once the sponsor selects names under first place, PoetrySoup sorts (does not rank) the winners by first name. After that a few names are randomly reshuffled so that the sorting by first name is not obvious. To verify, I removed the names that are out of place (not in aplha order by first name) and saw that remaining list is sorted in alpha order by first name. This is not an opinion blog. If you comment, please follow the steps I suggested, and share what you see. This is not about merits of placement--this blog is only about how winners are listed under a chosen rank. Just sharing my observation. No disrespect to anyone. Of course, there may be another explanation.

Contest Winner Medal 1 Hawaii's mocking parody - hiku Hilo Poet
Contest Winner Medal 1 Compose Andrea Dietrich
Contest Winner Medal 1 ASLEEP Anisha Dutta
Contest Winner Medal 1 WINTER HAIKU Ann Gilmour
Contest Winner Medal 1 voice of glory Gregory Richard Barden
Contest Winner Medal 1 CHILD'S THANKSGIVING Beata Agustin
Contest Winner Medal 1 The Blockaders James Marshall Goff
Contest Winner Medal 1 Somewhere Over the Rainbow Carol Mitra
Contest Winner Medal 1 autumn at hand Christuraj Alex
Contest Winner Medal 1 Shock diagnosis Richard Tipping
Contest Winner Medal 1 again and again Constance La France
Contest Winner Medal 1 Winter Canvas Debra L Brown
Contest Winner Medal 1 Dappled Winds Sam Kauffman
Contest Winner Medal 1 Bank Robbers Edward Ibeh
Contest Winner Medal 1 Land of my Fathers Wendy Watson
Contest Winner Medal 1 Knife's Edge Emile Pinet
Contest Winner Medal 1 School Closed Eve Roper
Contest Winner Medal 1 A mother's love Farah Diba Pastor
Contest Winner Medal 1 Spring's Arrival Frederic Parker
Contest Winner Medal 1 Snow moon Rama Balasubramanian
Contest Winner Medal 1 when dewdrops run dry JCB Brul
Contest Winner Medal 1 Nostalgia John Read
Contest Winner Medal 1 insecurity karen croft
Contest Winner Medal 1 Acquittal Clock Sotto Poet
Contest Winner Medal 1 The Poet And The Doctor L. J. Carber
Contest Winner Medal 1 BELOVED CHAOS Line Gauthier
Contest Winner Medal 1 Autumn Years Regina McIntosh
Contest Winner Medal 1 Innocence All Too Fleeting Robert Gorelick
Contest Winner Medal 1 'Shorty' Robert L. Hinshaw
Contest Winner Medal 1 My Avocado Fridge Sandra Haight
Contest Winner Medal 1 Melting In Bay Of Bliss Subimal Sinha-Roy
Contest Winner Medal 1 A Whimsical Dream Valsa George


Please Login to post a comment

Please stay on topic with your comments. Off topics comments may be removed. Thanks.



Characters Remaining:
Type the characters you see
CAPTCHA
Change the CAPTCHA codeSpeak the CAPTCHA code
 

Date: 3/17/2022 5:24:00 AM
Initially I was a little dejected seeing my name always at the bottom. Later I noticed that each poet had almost a certain position in the list. So I knew there must be some logic. Now I understand it fully !Thank you Vijay for explaining ! Also Congratulations on your great honor !
Login to Reply
George Avatar
Valsa George
Date: 3/17/2022 7:17:00 AM
Once again thanks Vijay !
Pandit Avatar
Vijay Pandit
Date: 3/17/2022 5:35:00 AM
I felt that way too until I figured out --some time ago--long before I wrote this blog. Exactly the reason I wanted you to read this blog. Thanks for reading and commenting.
Date: 2/26/2022 8:51:00 PM
Thanks Vijay! I was curious! Now it all makes sense. Congrats on your #1 new poem. So happy for this honor for you. Blessings!
Login to Reply
Pandit Avatar
Vijay Pandit
Date: 2/27/2022 2:32:00 PM
Many thanks, Sam, for reading my blog and commenting. Much appreciate.
Date: 2/20/2022 9:34:00 PM
Hey, congrats on your number one poem on best new poems list!
Login to Reply
Pandit Avatar
Vijay Pandit
Date: 2/21/2022 4:27:00 AM
Thanks Andrea.
Date: 2/20/2022 9:26:00 PM
I think you are right about this. Because I have an A name, i always am close to the top when I have one of the first place wins . it is a little bit embarrassing because I think people do not realize that the judges have nothing to do with this. it's totally going by whatever system Soup is using.
Login to Reply
Pandit Avatar
Vijay Pandit
Date: 2/21/2022 6:17:00 AM
Much elegance to your humble comment Ani. I enjoy reading your poems and know you are talented--nothing to be embarrassed about.
Jayasankar Avatar
Anitha Jayasankar
Date: 2/21/2022 6:08:00 AM
Same with me too Ria... It is a bit embarrassing for me too, as my name too starts with "A"
Pandit Avatar
Vijay Pandit
Date: 2/21/2022 4:26:00 AM
You have nothing to be embarrassed of Andrea. You are among TOP talents here and would be ranked high any way. Once people know poems are just sorted not ranked, they won't feel uneasy about the process. Thank you Andrea for taking the time to read and commenting.
Date: 2/20/2022 4:19:00 AM
I thought Brian ordered them alphabetically. Maybe you are right. Good observation!
Login to Reply
Pandit Avatar
Vijay Pandit
Date: 2/20/2022 8:27:00 AM
No Brian does not do that--I know that for sure. Thank you Rama for reading my blog and commenting.
Date: 2/19/2022 9:50:00 PM
Vijayji, just read your blog... Once, I have wondered how it all works, the ranking or sorting...but am actually not sure. I just enter contests for fun and inspiration, and enjoy writing for them... Maybe, those who sponsor lots of contests here, would be able to share their opinions better... God bless... ~ Ani
Login to Reply
Pandit Avatar
Vijay Pandit
Date: 2/20/2022 8:31:00 AM
Thank you Ani for taking the time to read my blog. The sorting is done by computer program--the logic for doing that is assigned by Poetry Soup.

Previous Blogs

 
Are You Curious?
Date Posted: 2/19/2022 8:56:00 AM

My Photos



Book: Reflection on the Important Things