Get Your Premium Membership
Arthur Vaso
(Click for Poet Info...)

Arthur Vaso is a Canadian poet, born and raised in Montreal, Quebec. He has had his works published in local papers/magazines as well as on many Web sites. He has traveled extensively around the world, and writes about a wide variety of topics.
 

Pros and Cons of AI in Poetry

Blog Posted by Arthur Vaso: 10/12/2024 5:17:00 PM

So many opinions, here is one more LOL

Heree is why this may not be a good thing. The popularity of AI language models like ChatGPT due to their apparent ability to generate content, including poetry, not a good idea. Such tools offer a new avenue that writers may explore in creative writing, students, and hobbyists, especially those looking far inspiration or playing around with style and form. However, while there is some merit in using AI for writing poetry, there is also the matter of its drawbacks when it comes to originality, artistic integraty, and possible abuses.

 

Benefits On the plus side, AI can help initiate the creative right brain. Many a time, writers suffer from a creative block; wherein the ChatGPT does help give them a quick-witted idea or draft that will help one succeed through their mental blocks. It's a teaching tool for amateurs and helps them learn different forms of poetry and wordplay, which is unthreatening for them. Above all, the model does the job instantly, thereby saving time, with literally limitless wordplay and rhyme-schemes.

However, most of these advantages come along with big pitfalls or disadvantages when one gets too reliant on AI while writing creative works.

Cons of Using AI for Poetry

1. Lack of Originality: The poetry AI comes up with is essentially based upon patterns and data it has been exposed to; it can often lack originality. While the AI may from time to time utter verses that may sound artistic or profound, it actually does not "feel" the words or have personal experiences from which to draw. True poetry usually flows from emotional depth and from personal insight coupled with an individual voice, something which, by its very nature, AI cannot truly emulate.

2. Limited creativity: While AI may observe certain ways and structures, it will most definitely cling to the more common words and clichés. It is not very good at thinking outside the box into unconventional forms or truly avant-garde poetry. Of course, this makes sense, because the model is limited by the data on which it's trained-so its creativity is really an imitation of what's come before, not an innovation of something new.

3. Encourages Laziness: One of the most salient negatives to utilizing AI for poetry would be the very real possibility and tendency for writers, especially students, to rely on it a bit too much. Rather than struggling through that cumbersome creation process of drafting, revising, and perfecting their own work, some would seek to have AI write full poems for them. The result is discouraging critical thinking and writing skills, and over time, depleting a person's ability to create work that is honest and personal.

4. It allows and enables cheating: Probably the worst drawback with AI for poetry is how it enables cheating. Students or wannabe poets might well pass off AI-generated poems as their own, with no hard work involved to refine their art. The teacher, editor, or reader has no idea that the work is not original, and may thus produce some distortion in assessing talent or effort. On campus, this can create a climate of deception where students employ AI to complete homework assignments for them without any active learning.

5. Dilution of Artistic Integrity: Poetry is, to date, an art that has its deep roots in human emotion, culture, and experience. Employing AI in its composition systematically eliminates that personal relationship the writer often experiences with the words. Such uses dilute the integrity of the art itself. A poem isn't just words; it's a mirror image of the poet's soul, which then gets lost when the poem is generated by AI.

Conclusion: Why Using AI for Poetry Isn't a Good Idea

While AI may be a fun, even useful, tool with which to play, or when one suffers from writer's block, the integrity of poetry as an art is at serious risk. Its lack of originality, being likely to encourage indolence, and assisting in cheating make it fairly problematic in educational and professional contexts. Writing poetry by means of AI minimizes the creative process vital for growth in every human respect.

Ultimatly, resorting to AI in poetry may save some time, but it definitely lacks authenticity and artistic value. A real poet would not give in to the temptation of an AI creative people's assistant; instead, he or she should nurture the test of coming up with a distinctive, creative and orginal voice.

 



Please Login to post a comment

Please stay on topic with your comments. Off topics comments may be removed. Thanks.



Characters Remaining:
Type the characters you see
CAPTCHA
Change the CAPTCHA codeSpeak the CAPTCHA code
 

Date: 5/31/2025 9:42:00 PM
Yes the possible benefits are no doubt there Arthur..Yet man will man-ip-ulate to wrong Avenues no doubt.' Hmm.? Weakness of character is inherent in our lunatic puppetmasters.'
Login to Reply
Date: 10/14/2024 1:25:00 AM
I meant using AI to cheat and bomb, not for good reasons LOL
Login to Reply
Date: 10/14/2024 1:24:00 AM
Anyone using AI should be in prison, its plain wrong.
Login to Reply
Date: 10/13/2024 5:42:00 AM
Art, a great blog. AI does have it's positive uses/needs but not in poetry. You made some very good points in your blog. I hope members stop using it to write poems.
Login to Reply
Date: 10/13/2024 1:24:00 AM
Your 5 points are spot on. It reminds me of this quotation which has inspired me for many years: "We can never learn too much about a poem, but always we come back to the work itself, for it exists not only as an historical object and the product of a particular mind and vision, but also in its own right, as an enduring work of art." Anon (1980) How to enjoy a poem. In Cook, C. (ed.), Pears cyclopaedia, 89th edition, Book Club Associates, London, p M3
Login to Reply
Richards Avatar
Suzette Richards
Date: 10/13/2024 1:26:00 AM
:)
Date: 10/13/2024 1:23:00 AM
Though provoking blog Arthur, I know it's used in medicine and is helping speed up diagnosis of diseases and cancers, so it does have a positive side, but to create poems using it and passing it off as your own is a big no from me. Tom
Login to Reply
Vaso Avatar
Arthur Vaso
Date: 10/13/2024 11:24:00 PM
In medicine it has actually already made a cure for a specific cancer, The title was specific to Poetry, however AI can be used for great good and also great evil. The IOF (Israeli Offensive Forces) has used it to slaughter 1000's of innocents, mostly children. Its a new world for sure now.
Date: 10/13/2024 12:41:00 AM
I very succinct and informative article xoxo
Login to Reply
Date: 10/12/2024 11:34:00 PM
Art, well done blog, very informative, for me the negatives of AI in poetry writing out do the positives, you know they have books that teach people how to write poetry, imagine that ! And, then there is the born poet, the reborn poet and the new born poet, that just writes from their heart and soul and they need no AI to help them do that, imagine that !
Login to Reply
Richards Avatar
Suzette Richards
Date: 10/13/2024 2:50:00 AM
Lol ... The shoe fits here: I fake it till I make it :)
Date: 10/12/2024 9:10:00 PM
Great blog, Art, and I hope many read it. I would like to point out that AI-generated work, especially poetry, is by its very nature, plagiarism as it cannot create, but relies entirely on the poems embedded in it's created memory bank (something I had blogged about many months ago). The biggest drawback as a teaching tool for poetry, is that it does not create accurate models (see my recent blog dealing with this aspect). Not only does it make the aspiring poets lazy to think for themselves, it also robs them of the chance to create their own poetic voice. An example of this is my poem, The Heir, where I wrote it in collaboration with AI - to research the topic of the poem and extract info.
Login to Reply
Richards Avatar
Suzette Richards
Date: 10/12/2024 9:30:00 PM
From the readers' perspective: Some might find it the kick-off board to stimulate new ideas (a bit like a computer generated writing prompt). I posit that this scenario is only valid when such AI material is clearly marked as such. As 100% AI material does not enjoy copyright, it is fair game. However, it is incumbent upon the author of such pieces to note the piece as such. Where only sections of the, eg poem, blog, etc, was AI produced, different legal points apply. Lastly, we as readers would not knowingly like to comment in the usual fashion on a AI-generated poem, but perhaps adjust our interactions, if we wish to comment at all.
Date: 10/12/2024 5:34:00 PM
Great blog Art, I hope you get lots of comments. I will be honest I have used chatgp once and that was when I was trying to write the blurb for my book to put on Amazon and my son said it needed to be more 'punchy' and loaded chat gp for me. I used some of the ideas it generated but put them into my own words . I would never use it to write poems and try to pass them off as my own work. hugs Jan xx
Login to Reply

Previous Blogs

 
Pros and Cons of AI in Poetry
Date Posted: 10/12/2024 5:17:00 PM
Darren White - Sad News
Date Posted: 6/10/2024 10:58:00 PM
Faten AlHariri, artist, painter,humanitarian
Date Posted: 7/13/2020 3:01:00 AM
Thank you to all the front line workers, Covid19
Date Posted: 5/19/2020 10:22:00 PM
MISSION ACCOMPLISHED
Date Posted: 12/31/2018 12:14:00 AM
NOW PLAYING - INTRINSIC BRIGHTNESS - DARREN WHITE
Date Posted: 12/23/2018 10:37:00 PM
NEWS RELEASE, VASO PUBLISHING INC
Date Posted: 12/19/2018 1:12:00 AM
Condolences and sympathies to Dear Eve Roper
Date Posted: 9/3/2018 8:58:00 PM
Breaking News ABBA is back!
Date Posted: 5/1/2018 11:27:00 PM
In Memory of Keith Bickerstaffe
Date Posted: 1/3/2018 1:52:00 AM
MERRY CHRISTMAS
Date Posted: 12/26/2017 1:28:00 AM
HAPPY BIRTHDAY TIM !!!!!!!!!!
Date Posted: 12/2/2017 8:40:00 PM
The Sound of Silence
Date Posted: 9/30/2017 7:54:00 PM
GUEST POET FREDERICK SPINNEY
Date Posted: 7/30/2017 10:20:00 PM
POETRYSOUP CHAT ANNIVERSARY
Date Posted: 7/8/2017 2:58:00 PM
UPDATE update update update yes an Update Darrens Garden
Date Posted: 7/3/2017 12:38:00 AM
UPDATE DARRENS GARDEN, additions by Chris Geen Eve Roper Lin Lane
Date Posted: 6/21/2017 7:42:00 PM
THE GARDEN OF EDEN
Date Posted: 6/19/2017 9:56:00 PM
How to build a better world with MARGARET ATWOOD
Date Posted: 4/22/2017 10:32:00 PM
I am Canadian
Date Posted: 4/13/2017 9:48:00 PM
INTERNATIONAL WOMEN’S DAY
Date Posted: 3/8/2017 7:55:00 PM
Save the Penguins’ - A blog for Darren White
Date Posted: 2/7/2017 7:20:00 PM
HAPPY NEW YEAR 2017
Date Posted: 12/31/2016 9:24:00 PM
MERRY CHRISTMAS 2016
Date Posted: 12/23/2016 6:55:00 PM
Collaboration by Seren Roberts and Tim Smith
Date Posted: 10/5/2016 10:34:00 PM

My Photos


photo

Book: Radiant Verses: A Journey Through Inspiring Poetry