Get Your Premium Membership

Interlocking Rubaiyat Contest - Follow-up - Angel L Villanueva's Blog

About Angel L Villanueva
(Show Details...)
Bloggers Photo

Poetry is an art form I have enjoyed for many years. I am particularly fond of the lyrical flow of classical poetry. I employ simplicity of words in my poems, but equally enjoy poetry in which elegant words and expressions are skillfully used.


Interlocking Rubaiyat Contest - Follow-up

Blog Posted:10/17/2021 2:16:00 PM

As a follow-up to the Interlocking Rubaiyat contest still in progress, I wanted to inform all who decide to participate as to what judging criteria will be used. It will aid me to better judge and assign placements to each poem entered in the contest. See the sample list below. Of course, evaluating a poem is subjective, but including a guide can help.

There are ten categories, and each can garner a score of between 0 through 10. The total score of all categories will determine a poem's placement. In case of a tie, the final placement will be at the discretion of the contest sponsor.

Also, to ensure the anonymity of the poem's author, I am refraining from viewing/reading any of the various pages listing recently posted poems.

So far, several noteworthy poems have been submitted. I hope others will join in and challenge themselves with the given form.

Criterion                                             Points

 

Adherence to poetic form used                10
Adherence to rules                                  7
Clarity of imagery and language                9
Coherence                                              9
Creativity                                                8
Cadence (meter & rhythm)                     10
Grammar                                               8
Originality                                              8
Overall poetic structure                           8
Rhyme                                                  8
    Total Score                                      85



Please Login to post a comment
Date: 10/20/2021 6:53:00 AM
Dear Poet and Dear Sponsor, good to find your rules, and to know how poems are marked in your contest. I found judging (especially the Premiere) a bit difficult, although tried my best...so thought of using a rubric, like I used as a teacher. Thanks for the follow-up. Best wishes ~ Mala
Login to Reply
Villanueva Avatar
Angel L Villanueva
Date: 10/20/2021 1:46:00 PM
Thank you for your comment, Mala. I do think the use of a scoring system is helpful when judging poems. It would aid in narrowing down the best ones. To that end, it seems to me that using a rubric would work.
Date: 10/18/2021 7:02:00 AM
Angel, does the poem have to be in meter ?
Login to Reply
La France Avatar
Constance La France
Date: 10/18/2021 3:07:00 PM
Angel, thanks for your reply. I do not know how to do either so I will have to skip this contest but I wish you success with the judging part, never easy _ peace and tranquility _Constance
Villanueva Avatar
Angel L Villanueva
Date: 10/18/2021 2:43:00 PM
Hi Constance. Yes, meter is required; iambic meter preferably, but for this contest a mix of iambic and trochee is allowed.
Date: 10/17/2021 9:21:00 PM
I hope to check out your contest sometime. Good luck with it, Angel
Login to Reply
Villanueva Avatar
Angel L Villanueva
Date: 10/18/2021 3:31:00 AM
Thank you, Andrea. I appreciate your kind expression.
Date: 10/17/2021 2:48:00 PM
Hi Angel, good idea and good contest. I will say, however, that the more complicated the requirements, the more likely 1) fewer entries, and 2) more entries that do not follow the rules. In my contest, for example, the rules are so simple: "TWO LINES OF RHYME ONLY, PLEASE!!!!! MORE THAN TWO LINES (A COUPLET) WILL BE ELIMINATED AUTOMATICALLY. Give me the best two RHYMING lines you think you've ever written." And, would you believe I am still getting full page poems that go on and on? Obviously, they didn't read the rules, so they are automatically eliminated. And, this is the second or third time I have done this same contest! Sad!!! Good luck, Angel.
Login to Reply
Villanueva Avatar
Angel L Villanueva
Date: 10/17/2021 3:43:00 PM
I agree, Milton. I have seen it much too often in other contests. It is unfortunate. However, my thought is that if a poet wants to improve his or her writing, learn new poetic forms and all that goes with them, then complexity may be part of the process. Why not challenge themselves? I do like your approach; it has certainly resulted in some beautifully penned lines. Thank you, Milton.

My Past Blog Posts

 
Interlocking Rubaiyat Contest Finalized
Date Posted: 11/3/2021 7:44:00 AM
Interlocking Rubaiyat Contest - Follow-up
Date Posted: 10/17/2021 2:16:00 PM
Hosting My First Contest - Interlocking Rubaiyat
Date Posted: 10/3/2021 9:19:00 AM

My Recent Poems

Date PostedPoemTitleFormCategories
11/25/2021 Reflection Quatrainage,childhood,introspecti
11/14/2021 The Last Red Tear Rubaiyatautumn,change,seasons,sno
11/2/2021 Again Quatrainage,longing,old,youth,
10/22/2021 Blue Marble Sonnetbeautiful,beauty,earth,sk
10/20/2021 Which One Is The Rose Free verseappreciation,beauty,roman
10/17/2021 Merging Dreams Free versebutterfly,dream,romantic,
10/17/2021 Beautiful Fall Acrosticautumn,beautiful,october,
10/17/2021 The Unknown Path Free versedesire,dream,longing,
10/15/2021 One Last Candle Sonnetlove,marriage,storm,toget
10/15/2021 The Blade Sonnetbible,metaphor,sin,
10/13/2021 Unforgotten Quatrainheartbreak,lost love,rela
10/13/2021 Urban Warfare Quatrainhumor,
10/12/2021 Walk With Me Free versehusband,love,marriage,rom
10/12/2021 Pawn Sonnetgames,
10/12/2021 This Leaf Free versepassion,romantic love,sim
10/11/2021 Darkened Soul Quatraindepression,longing,sad,
10/11/2021 Shades of Gray Rubaiyatdepression,longing,sad,
10/3/2021 End of Summer Enclosed Rhymeautumn,seasons,summer,
9/22/2021 Autumn's Hand Villanelleautumn,beauty,seasons,sep
9/15/2021 A New World Rubaiyatchange,faith,hope,paradis
9/14/2021 Nightmare Rubaiyatallegory,child,dream,
9/13/2021 Autumn's Return Quatrainautumn,color,seasons,sept
9/12/2021 Doomsday Clock Sonnethate,hope,peace,war,
9/2/2021 Autumn Tears Quatrainautumn,beauty,change,red,
9/1/2021 Lazy Summer Days Rubaiyataugust,beach,ocean,season
8/15/2021 Till Death Us Part Quatrainanniversary,marriage,roma
7/29/2021 Acceptance Pantoumbody,health,
7/27/2021 Morn Senryumorning,nature,
1/17/2021 Blue Jay Haikubeauty,bird,blue,song,
1/15/2021 The Name We Leave Rubaiyatcharacter,identity,rememb
1/13/2021 Alone With Silence Rubaiyatchange,faith,silence,soci
12/25/2020 Winter's Hold Sonnetseasons,snow,spring,winte
12/10/2020 Hall of Dreams Quatraindream,imagination,poems,p
12/6/2020 A Walk At Night Quatrainlove,moon,night,romance,s
11/29/2020 The Choice Sonnetcourage,devotion,enduranc
11/26/2020 Before He Goes Rhymedeath,farewell,for her,po
11/24/2020 To The King of The North Rhymebible,endurance,judgement
11/21/2020 Winter's Broken Promise Pantoumseasons,snow,winter,
11/18/2020 That Day Curtal Sonnetlove,marriage,romance,rom
11/15/2020 O Death Enclosed Rhymebible,death,faith,hope,st
11/10/2020 Strength To Cope Trioletendurance,faith,hope,trus
11/1/2020 November's Early Kiss Laynovember,october,seasons,
10/25/2020 Facing The Storms Sonnetendurance,faith,hope,life
10/18/2020 An Autumn Path Rubaiyatautumn,farm,nature,season
10/15/2020 Autumnal Days Quintain (English)autumn,beauty,change,octo
10/11/2020 Inner Beauty Sonnetage,beauty,flower,romanti
6/7/2020 Oppose Darkness Quaternendurance,faith,truth,
5/24/2020 To Death I Spoke Coupletdeath,dream,faith,hope,li
5/15/2020 A Healing In The Woods Sonnetage,fear,loneliness,memor
5/12/2020 Velvet Sky Sonnetbeauty,bible,creation,ear
5/12/2020 Spiritual Warfare Sonnetbible,devotion,endurance,
5/10/2020 Songs of Sunset Quatrainbird,poetry,song,sunset,
5/8/2020 Endless Dream Sonnetdream,imagery,romance,
5/7/2020 The Book of Motherhood Rhymechildren,mother,
5/7/2020 Intangible Coupletbeach,lost love,memory,ro
5/6/2020 See With Eyes of Faith Quatrainbible,faith,paradise,
5/6/2020 Come See Coupletbible,encouraging,hope,pa
5/6/2020 Long Is A Poet's Night Quatrainmuse,poems,write,writing,
5/5/2020 Winter's Call Sonnetbeauty,seasons,snow,winte
5/5/2020 The Cell Tells Sonnetappreciation,creation,lif
5/4/2020 If Only Quatrainmarriage,poetry,relations
5/4/2020 Raindrops Call Coupletmemory,rain,youth,
5/3/2020 Winter's Breath Quintain (English)seasons,snow,spring,winte
5/2/2020 Should Words Fail Me Quatrainlove,marriage,romantic,wi
5/2/2020 Dance of The Maple Seeds Rubaiyatappreciation,beauty,seaso
5/2/2020 Endless Bloom Sonnetappreciation,beautiful,lo
5/1/2020 Seasons Quatrainautumn,seasons,spring,sum
5/1/2020 Godly Faith Villanellededication,faith,religiou
4/29/2020 Write Your Dreams Rubaiyatdream,muse,poems,poetry,p
4/29/2020 To You, My Wife Villanellelove,romance,song,wife,
4/28/2020 What She Wants Quatrainlove,marriage,romance,wif
4/26/2020 Fleeting Peace Sonnetdeath,hate,peace,war,
4/26/2020 These Things Quatrainappreciation,beauty,earth

My Photos


Fav Poems

PoemTitleFormCategories
DEATH, WHERE ARE YOU Rhymeanxiety,death,grief,lonel
All too Soon Quatraindeath,life,
From Lily's Womb Coupletbirth,flower,
FOREVER AUTUMN Light Versedeath,seasons,tree,
ANOTHER TIME Dramatic Verseage,identity,
My Affair With A Frost Flower State Of Affairs Free versebetrayal,dark,emotions,he
Swallowed by the Night Rhymeanalogy,break up,heartbre
seasonal transitions Sonnetautumn,seasons,
These Days Rubaiyatworld,
Rumors of Unicorns Rubaiyatjourney,symbolism,
Arise My Son Rubaiyatchild,son,
Beautiful Mystery Sonnetdream,lost love,memory,my
Jubilee Coupletfantasy,happy,joy,
Life's Truth Coupletpain,rain,
Still I Run Villanelleautumn,death,truth,

Fav Poets

No Fav Poets Selected