Get Your Premium Membership

Monoku - Is It Poetry? - July Morning's Blog

About July Morning
(Show Details...)
Bloggers Photo

hi


Monoku - Is It Poetry?


Blog Posted:9/9/2018 5:30:00 PM

A while back a few blogs were written discussing the possibility that a single word might be considered "poetry."  What about Monoku?  A single line... poetry?  Nah, or so I thought (in my arrogance).  Why, anyone can write a single line, shucks, perhaps blindfolded and with one arm tied behind their back, I felt.  And then I read (and reread, and reread) Geoffrey Brewer's monoku (which coincidentally is the first place winer in my latest contest - see results below).  From life to death, from love to loss, all of humanity's dreams and hopes and finally, the end, all in one beautifully written single line of poetry.  The imagination runs wild as you picture two lovers caught up in the giddiness of true love.  The plans devised, the promises made.  But war can change everything.  Whether our protagonist found his peace at the end of his own gun or another the result remains the same... life is ever changing, nothing is ever guaranteed.  The children that were never born, each with unique genetic patterns that were only possible via the coupling of these two persons.  What would their names have been?  The grandchildren that never got to sit on Pawpaw's lap while he thrilled them with stories of love and adventure, or who never got a single taste of Nana's heavenly apple pie.  All of the big and little things in life - the glorious nights and the not so glorious fights, none of it ever got to happen.  A single nugget of lead smaller than a pinky finger was forcibly thrust into his fragile human brain ending everything.   All this and much more in one single line of poetry.  Magnificent!

Congrats to all who placed.

 

 

 

Please Login to post a comment
Date: 9/10/2018 8:07:00 AM
I felt this way as well when reading those type of poems (before I tried writing some). My mind works in parallels and for whatever reason this reminded me of the Pixar movie Ratatouille where the critic in the end realizes, "Not everyone can become a great artist, but a great artist can come from anywhere." In effect, not every brief poem is great poetry, but great poetry can be found in poems of any length.
Login to Reply
Kingston  Avatar
Wayne Kingston
Date: 9/10/2018 2:13:00 PM
What he said!
Date: 9/10/2018 7:31:00 AM
Brevity has its virtues. Ever tried reading The Rime of the Ancient Mariner!
Login to Reply
Morning Avatar
July Morning
Date: 9/10/2018 2:24:00 PM
What she said! Oh wait...
Date: 9/10/2018 2:27:00 AM
Thank you for your kind words, July. I have had the same thoughts about single lines of poetry, and even 2 or 3 lines, and sometimes feel that I am getting away with the easy option. I now confess that my monoku is derived from a rather longer poem (more words for your money!): ‘The Ballad of Miss Dutton - also on Poetry Soup. Perhaps this confirms that there can be a story hidden in the words of a monoku.
Login to Reply
Date: 9/10/2018 2:17:00 AM
Query: if we can agree that how one experiences/feels/emotes true love can be universally known without ANY words, shouldn't Monoku versification be able to approach exquisite, intentional poetic expression? :-)
Login to Reply
Trestrail Avatar
Keith Trestrail
Date: 9/10/2018 7:27:00 AM
What he said!
Date: 9/9/2018 7:51:00 PM
cont. - If the theme only applies to the writer ...thus out of context with your audience - even it has perfect form and all the poetic dynamics, the meaning may be lost or misinterpreted in a single word or Monoku. That style can also make poetry difficult for a novice reader to understand. One of the most beautiful scriptures in the bible is “Jesus wept”, just two words, but knowing the context impacts the reader. So yes, I believe a Monoku is true poetry.
Login to Reply
Date: 9/9/2018 7:45:00 PM
I understand poetry to be the artful arrangement of words (or a word) written in a condensed, logical and aesthetic manner to convey emotion or ideas to the reader. To make the greatest impact, the piece should to be centered around events such as wars or extreme emotions that have had a personal effect on your readers.
Login to Reply

My Past Blog Posts

 
Monoku - Is It Poetry?
Date Posted: 9/9/2018 5:30:00 PM
Daddy needs a new pair of Ray-Ban's (and other anomalous requests)
Date Posted: 8/23/2018 7:09:00 PM
Subliminal Plagiarism
Date Posted: 4/4/2018 5:57:00 PM
THE CHALICE OF MURDERED CROWS
Date Posted: 3/9/2018 10:07:00 AM
NEW CONTEST - POE MEETS PLATH
Date Posted: 2/4/2018 4:30:00 PM
On comments, support, and fried green tomatoes
Date Posted: 1/15/2018 5:45:00 PM
Daddy's Home!
Date Posted: 1/10/2018 5:13:00 PM

My Recent Poems

Date PostedPoemTitleFormCategories
9/17/2018 Vanessa - A Highlander Tale Haibunlonging,loss,
8/31/2018 The Most Unlovable Man in the World - Ashes to Ashes with Improvised Narration by Silent One Proseangel,hope,sad,
8/12/2018 She is Poetry Odeappreciation,tribute,
7/27/2018 The Most Unlovable Man in the World - Changeling Dramatic Monologueangel,anxiety,children,pe
7/17/2018 My Spirit Soars Lyricinspirational,
7/1/2018 To Love Her Sonnetdream,love,
6/18/2018 Ghost Wolf Rhymecommunity,howl,
6/3/2018 Mothers of the Lost Woods - The Finale Proseabsence,anxiety,appreciat
5/25/2018 Mothers of the Lost Woods - part 2 Proseallegory,anxiety,confusio
5/13/2018 Mothers of the Lost Woods - part 1 Proseanxiety,dream,mother,
4/20/2018 Maelstrom Haibunaddiction,adventure,lonel
4/15/2018 The Most Unlovable Man In The World - Love Thrives Dramatic Monologuechildren,inspiration,symp
4/15/2018 The Most Unlovable Man In The World - Parts 1 and 2 Dramatic Monologueabuse,bullying,hope,love,
4/3/2018 To Be Where She Is Haibunbeauty,loneliness,
3/21/2018 Detente Sonnetforgiveness,friendship,
3/19/2018 Debacle Dramatic monologuechristian,confusion,preju
3/16/2018 The Tempest in Thine Heart Romanticismangst,forgiveness,relatio
3/12/2018 A Vulcan Conundrum Narrativefunny,science fiction,
3/8/2018 Savage Garden Free verseculture,
3/3/2018 Death by Delirium - Poe's Untimely Demise Rhymeanxiety,death,
2/17/2018 O Death, Thou Hideous Beast Prosedeath,hope,
2/14/2018 Cherished is the Night Sonnetlove,
2/10/2018 Visitor Finale - with Maria Williams Narrativefantasy,love,
2/7/2018 Sweet Butterfly Elegydeath,grief,hope,
2/4/2018 Parallel Universe Free versebreak up,confusion,goodby
1/30/2018 Visitor 2 - With Maria Williams Narrativefantasy,love,
1/28/2018 Remember Me Free verselife,
1/24/2018 Urban Legend Rhymemurder,mystery,
1/21/2018 Visitor - A collaboration with Maria Williams Narrativeadventure,romance,science
1/17/2018 Judas Goat Rhymebetrayal,religion,
1/12/2018 Mary Rogers Lyricabuse,addiction,hope,ment
1/9/2018 The Spirit, The Water and The Blood Lyricfaith,forgiveness,murder,
1/6/2018 In a Field of Lavender She Lay Sonnetbereavement,love,
1/1/2018 Beware the Nones of May - For Becca Free verseabsence,betrayal,sad,
12/30/2017 Paloma-esque Free verseabsence,missing,
12/27/2017 The Devil's Game Rhymecorruption,death,vanity,
12/25/2017 Sentient Dust Lyricbible,god,song,
12/21/2017 A Conversation Narrativefunny,
12/14/2017 Surreality Rhymefantasy,metaphor,
11/22/2017 Fly me to the moon Rhymefantasy,farewell,,Lullaby
11/16/2017 Lonely Bird Free verseintrospection,
11/12/2017 Poetry, The Language Of Love Sonnetlove,poetry,,cute,
11/5/2017 Wondrous Sentience Free verseappreciation,beauty,faith
10/29/2017 July Morning Haibunloss,love,
10/20/2017 Nightgarden Romanticismabsence,love,
10/20/2017 Abyss Sonnetdepression,hope,
10/12/2017 White Lady Rhymeaddiction,
10/5/2017 When The Rain Stopped Falling Sonnetloneliness,love,

My Photos


photo

ps_death.png

Fav Poems

PoemTitleFormCategories
Hey Jude - Dedicated to Winged Warrior Pantoumlove,music,tribute,
I am Poetry Personificationbeauty,nature,poetry,
I Pass the Graveyard Terzanelledeath,sad love,winter,
Humanity Acrosticcommunity,happiness,human
I've Never Heard Snow Villanelleimagery,seasons,winter,
After Forever Free versetogether,
Loch Ness Free verseimagery,moon,nature,
FREE - A collaboration with Silent One Rhymeanalogy,freedom,peace,
One Brief Moment Rhymeimagery,nostalgia,
As fields become barren Proseanalogy,death,
Brave New World Free versebaptism,destiny,future,in
Nephilim Rhymegod,humanity,
A Near-to- death State Of Mind Narrativegoodbye,
VIOLIN Personificationlove,romance,
Captive Deep Blue Je Reviens Romanticismlonging,romance,sensual,v
The Turning Rhymecelebration,
Melancholic Tree Free verseanalogy,assonance,deep,sa
Storms and Love Free verselove,storm,war,
Enchanted moments Rhymelove,night,
Concrete Castle in the Sky Concreteart,god,
The Path Through Time Free versememory,time,
Immortal poetic lyrics Free verseanalogy,love,romance,
Shape Shapebeautiful,blessing,butter
Lover's Moon Sonnetlonely,love,moon,night,
Lemon Afternoon Ekphrasiscolor,imagery,sunset,
Nightstar Rhymefantasy,horse,love,
Dusk Free versesunset,

Fav Poets

No Fav Poets Selected