Get Your Premium Membership

Let the Student Have a Say

The new strategy schoolchildren are learning is called ‘find your voice’. Amazing to me, as I think many of them have definitely already found theirs. When I was a school child, we were not encouraged to find our voice. We were rather encouraged to lose ours. Wait. I am wrong. We were not allowed to have a ‘voice’. We were the children, not on the same “playing level” as adults. Today’s student is encouraged to buy into the school system by helping to plan it. The theory is if they do not have a say, and they are not able to express their voice, They do not “have” to buy into the system. They could not possibly buy in. We did not have a voice. We were taught to behave though. We did not have any say, or any freedom, or any power. The teachers were all-powerful in the ‘good ole’ days’. Which was okay if you had an honest, fair, teacher. But…well, you know there were some mean horrible ones out there. On the other hand, we were taught to memorize, and we did not question why. School was our job, and we wanted to do our job. We respected our parents, and our parents respected school, so we respected school also. A voice? We did not need one. We had multiplication, we had spelling, we had reading we had a parent, and we had a teacher. Some were wonderful, others shut us completely down, but we still tried to learn something. Psychologically, we were brilliant, because we quickly learned to not share ideas unless they were the teacher’s ideas. I am still pondering the concept of student voice. Interesting, huh?

Copyright © | Year Posted 2018




Post Comments

Poetrysoup is an environment of encouragement and growth so only provide specific positive comments that indicate what you appreciate about the poem.

Please Login to post a comment

Date: 11/6/2018 10:54:00 AM
Very interesting...I went to a catholic school, we had nuns as teachers for most of the grades. "there were some mean horrible ones out there"; now that sums up catholic school very well. My Mom laid down the law though; no one was permitted to spank or punish us except for our parent's. With the exception of writing lines which usually took up recess for several weeks; especially any crime that warranted 5000 or more lines.
Login to Reply
Krutsinger Avatar
Caren Krutsinger
Date: 11/6/2018 11:30:00 AM
Oh, my gosh. 5000 lines. I would have loved that!
Date: 11/2/2018 3:37:00 PM
Dear Caren, you're treading on quick sand in this write. Children (young or old) do not have the experience of life nor the wisdom. I'm reminded of a biblical king who ignored the wisdom of his elders in favor of his young friends – it proved a disaster. Children are impulsive, they play favorites, often to see what they can get out of them for selfish reasons. Hope you're tolerant enough to allow another's viewpoint. Thanks for stopping by, always appreciative. / M
Login to Reply
Krutsinger Avatar
Caren Krutsinger
Date: 11/2/2018 11:24:00 PM
I believe I am tolerant enough to not only allow, but welcome your opinions, my friend. Thank you for the stop-by. It has delighted me totally!
Date: 11/2/2018 10:29:00 AM
This is definitely different. And while I like the idea of kids feeling engaged and confident... I think something was lost in the respect/ behavior end of things. I wish they would teach those two things FIRST and then give them their "voice"!
Login to Reply
Mcferran Avatar
Rhona Mcferran
Date: 11/2/2018 4:54:00 PM
Hahahaha... yes, I forget! ;)
Krutsinger Avatar
Caren Krutsinger
Date: 11/2/2018 10:56:00 AM
You are preaching to the preacher of the choir here.

Book: Reflection on the Important Things