Get Your Premium Membership

Which Would You Choose, Brave Soupers

[This is an email I sent to our nephews Mother's Day; it ends with a hard question all of us might want to consider asking ourselves in this epidemic.] 'W. and I went to put flowers on Grandma's grave; while she was arranging the flowers and chatting with her mom's spirit, I did my favorite thing in a cemetery and walked around trying to get a glimpse of the lives the dead once lived. Funny thing is, at least 2/3 of them didn't love as long as I have. [I have read that 1/3 of the population never makes it to 65!] Now the sad news: your aunt and I are slowly dying--of boredom! Who knew house arrest would be so hard? On you guys too--no partying! But one good thing is that maybe now we fat and happy Americans will stop taking things for granted, like health, prosperity, life! Death is always at your shoulder from the day you're born.We've tried to sanitize it, but death has had enough and now shouts from the rooftops, "No freakin' way, you puny humans! I can kill you with a handshake or a sneeze, and you'll never see it coming!" Of course, in our modern secular hubris, we're sure we'll get one up: a vaccine, perhaps a medical miracle treatment like antibiotics seemed 80 years ago. But this bug might just be a precursor to something even worse, like a variant on Ebola or the bubonic plague that killed up to 1/2 of humanity in the 14th century (and is still around, folks!). From then till the Spanish Flu of 1918 [which killed my great-uncle and great-aunt], the world was raked by epidemics every 5-6 years. People died, sometime like flies. Curiously, the strange thing is that in those more lethal times, people were generally more religious, i.e., open to at least the chance something of them would survive the death of their bodies. How true is that nowadays, even amongst some who call themselves religious? Let me contrast 2 communities subject to a deadly disease. In 1665 the English village of Eyam had an outbreak of plague. Many wanted to flee, though they knew this would spread the disease. The pastor of the parish church convinced the village to quarantine-- for a year!--thereby sparing the nearby villages. About 2/3 of the 300 villagers died in that time. Contrast that with Martha's Vineyard where the locals, fearing a far less lethal disease, Covid-19, wanted to keep off the island the New Yorkers fleeing to their summer homes, properties the New Yorkers owned. Which village would you be in? Fess up--it's good for the soul! love, old uncle'

Copyright © | Year Posted 2020




Post Comments

Poetrysoup is an environment of encouragement and growth so only provide specific positive comments that indicate what you appreciate about the poem.

Please Login to post a comment

Date: 11/18/2020 2:26:00 PM
Hi LJ: Interesting question. I believe with this virus there are more vulnerable subjects who can stay locked down. The rest of society should get on with living, or there will be no economy left to sustain us and no herd immunity. Interesting how it rears it’s ugly head - right near an election.....just saying. SuZ
Login to Reply
Carber Avatar
L. J. Carber
Date: 11/19/2020 7:05:00 AM
I thought about that too, Suzanne, and I've come to believe based on my own bizarre experiences that chance is the illusion and we all are 'little puzzles', part of a grand puzzle called history. The mysteries of life, sentience, and God are not easy to unravel, perhaps because there is so very, very much meaning to the Universe.
Date: 8/25/2020 4:29:00 PM
Greeting, LJ. I have read your proposition once before now, - I began to answer the dilemma you pose, then I deleted it. I would stay, generally speaking. Lock down is a treatment for the virus. I can understand people wanting to leave,- lock down atmosphere is oppressive. Thanks for this post, it's a necessary inspection of current human behaviour. Interested to know where your heart lies with this. Prose showed me good arguments, but neutrality.
Login to Reply
Ermine Avatar
Sigrid Ermine
Date: 9/8/2020 9:09:00 PM
I agree (my perception) with your assertion that society today is more selfish, less God focused than a couple of hundred years ago. Land ownership I guess, has a lot of bearing on society's ability to 'shut down' completely for the virus. More people these days owe years worth on income on their property. We're swept up, and in a more crowded world.
Carber Avatar
L. J. Carber
Date: 8/26/2020 12:37:00 PM
Sigrid,I posed the question because I think most of us might not be as self-sacrificing today as the villagers of Eyam were, mainly because the sense of God and soul is much less common today in our secular, materialist world-- and so many fear death as extinction. I learned the hard way death is a door, not a wall, so I would stay. What would you do?
Date: 7/19/2020 1:39:00 PM
I enjoyed reading this L.J. This time we have because of Covid-19 is the perfect time for reflection. Blessings xxoo
Login to Reply
Carber Avatar
L. J. Carber
Date: 7/22/2020 8:04:00 AM
Thank you Connie-- and may you and yours go with God in these fraught times....

Book: Reflection on the Important Things