Poetry Forum Areas

Introduce Yourself

New to PoetrySoup? Introduce yourself here. Tell us something about yourself.

Looking for a Poem

Can't find a poem you've read before? Looking for a poem for a special person or an occasion? Ask other member for help.

Writing Poetry

Ways to improve your poetry. Post your techniques, tips, and creative ideas how to write better.

High Critique

For poets who want unrestricted constructive criticism. This is NOT a vanity workshop. If you do not want your poem seriously critiqued, do not post here. Constructive criticism only. PLEASE Only Post One Poem a Day!!!

How do I...?

Ask PoetrySoup Members how to do something or find something on PoetrySoup.


You have an ad blocker! We understand, but...

PoetrySoup is a small privately owned website. Our means of support comes from advertising revenue. We want to keep PoetrySoup alive, make it better, and keep it free. Please support us by disabling your ad blocker on PoetrySoup. See how to enable ads while keeping your ad blocker active. Also, did you know you can become a PoetrySoup Lifetime Premium Member and block ads forever...while getting many more great features. Take a look! Thank you!

The Battle of the Vitasta

Ram R. V. Avatar Ram R. V. - Premium MemberPremium Member Send Soup Mail  Block poet from commenting on your poetry

Below is the poem entitled The Battle of the Vitasta which was written by poet Ram R. V.. Please feel free to comment on this poem. However, please remember, PoetrySoup is a place of encouragement and growth.

Read Poems by Ram R. V.

Best Ram R. V. Poems

+ Follow Poet

The poem is below.


Poet's Notes
(Show)

Notes

The Battle of Vitasta: (Or the Battle of the Hydaspes) was fought by Alexander the Great in 326 BC against King Porus of the Paurava kingdom on the banks of the Hydaspes River (now known as the Jhelum River) in what is now the Punjab Province of Pakistan. The battle resulted in a complete Greek victory.

Harold Bloom: (b. 1930) Harold Bloom is a Poststructuralist critic and Sterling Professor of Humanities at Yale University, US; often associated with Derrida, de Man, Miller and Hartman.

King Porus: original name Raja Purushottama, was a king of the Pauravas, Ruler of a territory now known as the Punjab (and now in Pakitan), and reigned between 340 – c. 315 BC,  who fought fiercely and skilfully against Alexander the Great in the Battle of Vitasta;  was reinstated though defeated in the battle, for his courage and soldierly qualities. 340 – c. 315 BC . Assassinated in 315 BCE by a Greek general.

King Alexander: (356 – 323 BCE) Alexander the Great, Conqueror and king of Macedonia, was born on July 20, 356 – 323 BCE in Pella, Macedonia. During his leadership, from 336 to 323 B.C., united the Greek city-states, also  became the king of Persia, Babylon and Asia, and created Macedonian colonies in the region; known for his leadership and nobility. Was Aristotle’s disciple.

Arrian: a Greek historian, public servant, military commander and philosopher of the Roman period.

Zhukov: (1896 – 1974), Gen. Zhukov was a Soviet-Russian officer in the Red Army of the Soviet Union who became Chief of General Staff. He made this claim in his lecture, delivered at the Indian Military Academy at Dehradun, in 1957.

GOK: God Only Knows

“for want of a rider,… the battle was lost” : adaptation of a Nursery Rhyme

“Truest friend and noblest foe”: an echo of  Tennyson’s 'Home they brought her warrior dead':

 

 

 

 

 


Become a Premium Member and post notes and photos about your poem like Ram R. V..


The Battle of the Vitasta

While textualizing history
(now after nearly 24 centuries)
Of the Battle of the ‘Vitasta,’ or ‘Hydaspes’
Or the Jhelum (a name now common),
There’s bound to be some swerve,
Which is how (according to Bloom)
Poetry is born—
Now that there are claims and counter-claims:
Alexander conquered India,
(by courtesy of Arrian);
No, he fled, a hypothesis
As advanced, notably by Zhukov
(Who, it is claimed, would know 
A fleeing force if he saw one).
How did Zhukov happen to see 
Alexander's army fleeing?
GOK!

But this is not an attempt to romanticize the battle,
Glorifying either Alexander and his Bucephalus
Or King Porus and his valiant elephant.	
Now, if we go by Arrian, what’s the bottom line? 

You were wounded, King Porus, 
But it did not matter to you in the least;
But your elephant was killed, 
Which decided the end of the great battle.

You fought fiercely— till the end.
So did your men,
But only until you collapsed.
Then they started fleeing 
As would any troop in those times—
In the circumstances.

And they were chased by the Greek garrison (in reserve)
That joined from across the Jhelum— 
A neat plan that Alexander had thought out
And it worked.
Alas, for want of a rider,… the battle was lost!

Come to think of it, 
Yours after all was a top-down system, 
As was any such system (Alexander’s included),
Until modern times, which would collapse,
Like a quake-hit city,
When the leader falls. 

But that was not the end of the story.
The best is yet to be, as we know.
For you, Porus, it was dignity even in defeat.
And Alexander happened to be
The truest friend and noblest foe.
You, now in chains, asked to be treated as a King.
So, you were reinstated and made the Satrap
(the Governor of the Greek Dominon).

The lesson (or one of the lessons) 
that we have learnt from your battle,
King Porus, is this:
Any good team should have a Second-in-command!

***

Copyright © | Year Posted 2017

Post Comments

Please Login to post a comment
Date: 9/1/2017 8:48:00 AM
I thoroughly enjoyed this poem of history. It brought me closer to understanding the human side of such large figures.
Login to Reply
R. V. Avatar
Ram R. V.
Date: 9/1/2017 9:43:00 AM
Thank you very much, Patricia, for your profound remarks. You will be my voice! I had to do quite a lot of referencing for the poem. Now I feel amply rewarded:) By the way, post your photo. Otherwise, you will only be my disembodied voice!
R. V. Avatar
Ram R. V.
Date: 9/1/2017 9:43:00 AM
Thank you very much, Patricia, for your profound remarks. You will be my voice. I had to do quite a lot of referencing for the poem. Now I feel amply rewarded:). By the way, post your photo. Otherwise, you will only be my disembodied voice!