Poetry Forum

home recent topics recent posts search faq

Forum Home » High Critique » Shattered Glass

For poets who want unrestricted constructive criticism. This is NOT a vanity workshop. If you do not want your poem seriously critiqued, do not post here. Constructive criticism only. PLEASE Only Post One Poem a Day!!!
6/19/2010 12:05:41 PM

Friendship - such a fragile thing of which we all yearn to get hold

Like a wine glass, eloquence of status and acceptability

Yet, often we over-indulge on this wine, drunk on exploitation

Control rests within our hands, but one slip up and glass is broken

Squeeze too hard and the glass shatters, grip too loosely and it falls

And all that’s left is broken glass at your feet, unable to piece back together

Often times, when you break that glass, you try to sweep up the pieces

Cradling it in bloody hands, making your skin sting

Desperately you try to mop up this mess, but all you’ve accomplished are shard-pierced fingers

Forever scarred when you tried to mend a friendship beyond disrepair

Visible to any and all around you

A painful reminder of how fragile a friendship really is
permalink • reply with quote
6/20/2010 9:24:48 PM

James Marion
Posts: 10
In general:
You want to use the least amount of words to say the most you possibly can. A good example would the use of "squeeze" and "grip" in the same line.
In general, especially when the syllabic count of each line doesn't matter, there is no excuse to contract. (It's)
Embrace the period. In a free form poem like this, it is not unusual for authors to forget about them completely. However, there are clear sentences in here; make them clearer.

"of which" muddied up the first line; consider rewriting it in a more concise way.
"Like" similes are often intrusive; in the second line, simply saying "a wine glass" would make friendship a more powerful metaphor.
"Over-indulge" is redundant. Also, wine does not need to be repeated, necessarily.
"Within" could be in, "slip up" should be hyphenated. However, given the verbose writing style, "slip-up" seems a little colloquial for this poem.
Learn the power of the semi-colon, especially for juxtaposition.
Watch your tense and word choice - "All that is left is broken glass" and "unable to piece back together" seem very strange together.
"Scarred" also messes with the perception of tense.
Watch your use of comma; it could be used far more effectively in many parts of this piece. For example, "Visible to any and all around you" implies the sentence "visual to all around you", which makes the sentence redundant; however, I believe what you intended to say is "Visual to any, and all around you", continuing onto the next line.
"Shard-pierced fingers" doesn't make sense in light of "mopping up the mess". What are you doing? Are you "sweeping" (line 7), "mopping" (line 9), or "cradling" (line 8)?
permalink • reply with quote

Forum Home » High Critique » Shattered Glass

Powered by AspNetForum © 2006-2010 Jitbit Software